Vocalcrux

Hear what they’re really arguing about.

It listens to a conversation. When people talk past each other, it names what they’re really disagreeing about and asks them one question.

Listening · Braver Angels · 55:39

“Who would have to be in that room for each of you to accept what it decided?”

What they’re really arguing about: who gets the final say on a disputed question in an emergency.

Listens

Live, or on the recording.

A laptop in the room, or your episode afterwards. It writes down what is said and tells the voices apart as it goes.

What it listens to

Debates, interviews and panels.

From one to three hours, two speakers or seven.

Names it

The disagreement under the argument.

Each side brings a view the other side’s points never reach. It says what each one is, in their own words.

John Gable and Joan Blades, at 18:55

The conversation they are really having is about what makes a changed mind a good one. John brings the view that people judge well when they see every side and decide for themselves. Joan brings the view that people only listen, and rightly move, through caring relationships.

Asks

One question, to both.

Short enough to read aloud. When nothing is being missed, it says nothing.

18:55

When Joan’s friend Jacob put climate on his list because he cares about her, had he come to see more of the picture, or come to trust someone new, and does it matter which?

“When you watch one person hit another, how does the wrongness of it reach you, compared with how the blue of a blue circle reaches you?”

Asked of Alex O’Connor and Destiny, at 63:40

For debate shows

A question for your moderator, live.

Learn more

For podcasts

Every moment two guests talked past each other.

Learn more

For organisations

For conversations across a divide.

Learn more

Free first run

Send us your next recording.

Get in touch

Try it on your next one.

The first run is free. Send a recording, or tell us when you’re next live.