How it works

It listens for the moment two people stop hearing each other.

Most arguments that go nowhere aren’t about what they seem to be about. Each side is living by a different story, and the other side’s arguments never reach it.

Three things, in order.

It reads back over the conversation every few minutes, so a question rests on what both sides have actually said.

Listens

Live or recorded.

A laptop in the room, or your recording afterwards. It writes down what is said and tells the voices apart.

Names it

The real disagreement.

When two sides talk past each other, it says what they are really arguing about: the view each one brings that the other’s argument never reaches.

Asks

One question, to both.

Built from their own words and short enough to read aloud. When nothing is being missed, it says nothing.

One real moment.

At a Braver Angels evening, Francis Collins and Wilk Wilkinson had both just said they’d welcome a full review of how the pandemic was handled.

At 55:39, what it said they were really arguing about

The conversation they are really having is about who gets the final say on a disputed question in an emergency. Collins treats the pandemic like a war: qualified bodies debate, then the government acts, and loud outside voices make things worse. Wilkinson treats free citizens as the judges: dissent must be argued out in public, not shut down, before anyone is bound.

The question it asked them both

You both said you’d welcome a full review of how the pandemic was handled, like the reviews hospitals hold after a patient dies. Who would have to be in that room for each of you to accept what it decided?

What it doesn’t do.

It doesn’t pick a winner, check facts or tell anyone what to think. It quotes both sides fairly and asks the question they both have to answer.

Try it on your next one.

Send us a recording, or tell us when your next debate is. You get back every question it asks, with the moment each comes from.